My Sisters Keeper free essay sample

Cloning is a controversial topic to where most people who argue about it, definitely do not agree with each other’s opinions. â€Å"My Sister’s Keeper† is a movie where one child, Anna, is conceived solely so her older sister Kate can fight leukemia. Once Anna reaches a certain age, she realizes what has been happening to her and refuses to go through with anything else by suing her mother. Throughout the movie, this situation tears the family apart and members of the family are heartbroken but it ultimately helps decide the outcome of what should happen (Cassavetes, 2009). In the movie â€Å"My Sister’s Keeper†, a girl named Kate is diagnosed with leukemia at a very young age. After running tests the parents find out that they along with the younger brother to Kate, are no matches for Kate to receive anything from them. The parents then decide it would be a good idea to have another child made specifically to be a match for Kate, which was suggested by another doctor. We will write a custom essay sample on My Sisters Keeper or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page Another child is later born, Anna, and Kate is finally able to be healthy again and return back to a normal life. As many years pass Kate ends up with leukemia again and this time Anna understands what has been happening to her since she has been born and refuses to give her sister anything else. Anna ends up going to a lawyer and suing her mom for medical emancipation. The audience later finds out that Kate is the person that made Anna go to a lawyer and do this because Kate no longer wants to live. After all of the court hearings and going back and fourth with the judge trying to decide what to do, Anna won the case against her mom and became medically emancipated. During this entire process with the court, Kate ended up dying (Cassavetes, 2009). Kate’s mom’s actions are best supported by the ethical terms deontology and medical paternalism. Deontology is doing the right act and having the best motive regardless of the consequences. Kate’s mom expressed deontology when she had decided that it was fine if she had used Anna for Kate’s medical problems since before Anna was ever created. Medical paternalism is when people believe they know what is best for others; as in when Kate’s mom believed what she was doing was right regardless of the opinions anyone else had. Her mom was not able to accept the fact that her daughter was dying and did not want to deal with it. Ethical terms that opposed Kate’s mom’s actions are nonmaleficence is doing harm to another while nonconsequential ethics is the rightness or wrongness of an action based on the consequences of the action. Kate’s mom was causing nonmaleficence by putting Anna through all these unnecessary surgeries. During the time, Anna had no idea what was going on and had no say in the things she wanted. Kate’s mom thought that it was ok for her to conceive another child for the good of her first born. Kate’s mom would constantly have Anna as a back up to use in case something went wrong with Kate. Autonomy is when an individual makes his or her own decisions. In the movie, I believe Anna’s rights are most important compared to Kate’s or her moms. In my opinion I believe that Kate and Anna’s mom was completely wrong for what she had done and how she thought nothing was wrong with it. Anna’s life was only created to help her sister survive. From the day Anna was born, tests and procedures began to help keep Kate alive. Anna was of course way too young to understand what was happening to her and why. When Anna reached the age of thirteen, she was fully aware of what she had been going through since the day she was born and no longer wanted anything to do with it. At this age, Anna was able to comprehend what was happening to her and why, and even though she did want to help her sister fight leukemia, she and her sister Kate were tired of fighting. Anna stuck by Kate’s side throughout the entire situation, as Kate was the person who encouraged Anna. She told Anna to hire a lawyer and fight for medical emancipation from her parents since she was never before allowed to state her consent. Kate had been completely accepting of her because she was tired of fighting and she knew it was coming. The ethical implications from the nurses are that they continued to do their job despite their opinions in what they thought was right or wrong. Even if the nurse did not agree with what the family was doing, they still had a job to do; deontology. Cloning is a huge ethical and moral issue to the point where not everybody can agree on the same thing. In the movie, all the mother was trying to do was save her first born child from dying but did not realize the kind of physical pain she was also putting her other daughter in. This ethical dilemma created many problems within the family and until Kate eventually died from leukemia, the fighting had stopped and the Anna had gotten what she and her sister had finally wished for; peace. My Sisters Keeper free essay sample Reading Logical Jostle: My Sisters Separator: Jodi Peculated I Finished the text: 11/03/textile Source: Novelette of publication: enhance you pick it up, you can never put it down. This family tragic drawn you in every moment and get interesting and interesting because everybody gets a chapter and you read it from the point of views of Anna, Sara, Brian, Campbell (Annas Lawyer), Jesse (Annas Brother), Julia and lastly Kate (Annas sister), but we dont get Skates point of view until the end. Also Saras point of view is staged mainly in the flashbacks. Its very ass to lose yourself that Jumps through narrative to narrative through time. And all of this is happening within two weeks, by separating the novel into individual day. With each characters narratives, you begin to sympathies with each and every one of them. When I first began reading the novel, I warned of two things, that I would cry like a baby and that it will break my heart, and it successfully did. We will write a custom essay sample on My Sisters Keeper or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page At the beginning I had a very clear view on the situation that Sarah was wrong and Anna was right. I thought: how could you ask your child to do something that would endanger her life? It didnt occur to me that by Anna refusing to donate her kidney Kate would definitely die. It didnt occur to me that Sarah was only trying to save her child. Its very interesting to see everyones side of the story. Throughout Brains narrative you see how tough it is to have a child who is dying. Throughout Sarahs narrative you realize how demanding and challenging it is for her to try and save all her children, both physically and emotionally. Throughout Jessie narrative you see how difficult it is for him to know that his family has given up on him. Throughout Annas narrative I didnt like Sarah; she seemed to be neglecting Anna and favoring Kate, yet until the end I didnt quite understand her intentions for filing a lawsuit. I understood her reasoning for not wanting to be used, yet by having a sister I knew that no matter what, I would always do whatever it took to save her. The audience is denied the answer to why, right until the end, where the twist really comes in. Even though, in real life this kind of situation doesnt happen a lot but in some situations in this kid of matter parents will have to result to this e. A family in the UK was exactly in the same situation and they has to especially to get permission from the Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority (HAVE). Using IF techniques a cell will be removed from the specially selected embryo and checked that it is disease-free and a good tissue match. Using this technique Gain will have an 80% chance of a match being found, compared to a 20% chance from a brother or sister conceived naturally. This familys experience is very similar to the book, it made me realize that parents would do anything to save heir child. In my opinion, since them both are designer baby they do have a right to their own bodies, since they have a right to say. think the Authors purpose is to not only entertain readers with a really good story but to also explain to readers about the causes of cancer and the effects it can have on a family. My Sisters Keeper is a deeply moving novel on one of the most sensitive issues known to mankind. A novel which will definitely cause tears. My Sisters Keeper (Personal Response) By Michelangelo